All Things Shining
30 Oct 2021 - 15 Jan 2026
- book by Hubert Dreyfus and and Sean Dorrance Kelly
- The very different moral world of Homeric Greeks
- A chapter on David Foster Wallace and nihilism
That is the real reason that Wallace and Gilbert are appropriate for this book: not because they sense the lostness of the age—this dark vision was alive already in Eliot’s Wasteland and Beckett’s Endgame, and countless other testimonies from the early part of the twentieth century. No, what makes these contemporary authors worth reading instead is that they are trying to find a way into the light. In seeing how they fail, we will prepare ourselves to search for the sacred possibilities still alive in the modern world.
- p44
- Huh Garry Wills hated it (via WS) 'All Things Shining': An Exchange | Hubert Dreyfus, Sean Dorrance Kelly, Garry Wills | The New York Review of Books
- Unpaywalled original Superficial & Sublime? | Garry Wills | The New York Review of Books
- not a very enlightening conflict, I'm sorry to say
- A chapter on Moby Dick
Ahab’s pursuit of Moby Dick is, in effect, a monomaniacal pursuit of the final, ultimate truth about the way things are. “If man will strike, strike through the mask!” But there are no such final truths in Melville’s world; no reasoning thing stands behind the unreasoning mask. Ahab’s determination to find such a foundation—that is the wicked core of his monomaniacal monotheism.